Are upright walkers better than canes?

We believe that some people are better suited for using a cane while others are better suited for using an upright walker for seniors. A person’s condition, type of disability, weight, body shape, and budget all play a role in determining which device is the best fit. After you read this article, we hope you’ll be able to answer that question with more clarity. This post is perfect if you’re looking for advice on which mobility device to use or whether to use one at all. We’ve provided information on what they can do and how they work so that it will be easier for you to make the most informed decision possible when it comes down to your health care needs.

Using a cane or walker to retain your mobility may be beneficial if you have a spinal ailment that affects your freedom to walk or have just undergone back surgery. Canes and walkers have a simple interface but upright walkers have some significant benefits: they improve function, prevent injuries, and eliminate stress on your spine. There are many different types of assisted mobility aids on the market these days, and the guidelines below will help you choose the right cane or walker for you.

What’s in an assessment:

Yes, someone can determine they need mobility assistance and then walk into a pharmacy or medical supply store and buy one off the shelf. According to research, 70% of canes are used incorrectly or are the incorrect height or design for the user. A poor decision might compromise stability and increase the chance of falling. If it’s too low, they’ll stoop forward, which will affect their posture and cause back pain. 

A physical therapist can examine your gait, ensure that your gadget is correctly suited to you, and teach you how to use it. Some individuals believe that if you have a troublesome knee or hip, you should use a cane on the side that aches. However, you should apply it with the hand that is opposite the hurting joint. To keep you steady, it puts your weight onto the cane and away from your weaker side.

Which is better, a cane or a walker?

The amount of support you require and whether you need it for one or both limbs will determine whether you use a cane or a walker. Mobility issues fall into one or more of the following three categories:

  • Weight-bearing (because of weakness or pain).
  • Balance (related to coordination or sensory problems, such as numbness or low eyesight).
  • Endurance (due to coordination or sensory problems, such as numbness or low vision) (due to heart or lung problems).

The optimum type of gait aid is determined by the category that best describes your problem. 

A cane can provide one-sided support by lowering the weight on the joint if you have modest limb weakness, such as a creaking knee. Mild sensory alterations, such as impairments in vision, hearing, or balance, can also benefit from the use of a cane. A cane, for example, maybe more beneficial for someone with a mild balance impairment caused by peripheral neuropathy or limited vision since they can feel the floor through the arm carrying the cane.

You have a number of alternatives when it comes to selecting a tool to assist you in moving more effectively. However, determining which type is ideal for you might be difficult. You should discuss the device you should obtain with your health care practitioner. 

Canes and walkers each have their own set of advantages and disadvantages. If you’re debating between a cane and a walker, here are some considerations to keep in mind : 

1. Why did you decide to purchase the gadget in the very first place?

Canes are best for issues that only affect one side of the body, whereas walkers are better for discomfort that affects both sides. 

2. How much of your body weight must be supported by the device?

Some walkers can support up to 50% , whereas canes can sustain up to 25% of your weight.

3. What level of device stability do you require? 

Walkers offer the most stability, although four-point canes can also help with balance and spine protection.

4. What level of device agility do you require? 

Because walkers with seats can not be used on stairs, a cane could be a better option if you need to go up and down.

Factors to consider while choosing a Gadget :

Consider the following factors while choosing the right gadget for you:

After you’ve selected what sort of mobility device you’ll get, you’ll need to figure out which one to get and ensure it fits you correctly. Don’t worry, and you won’t be making these selections on your own: your health care professional will assist you in finding the best product for mobility and explain to you how to use it correctly. 

Factors to consider while purchasing gadget: 


Canes are classified into three groups:

  1. Standard: This is the most basic form of cane, and it generally has a T-shaped handle. It can aid with stability, but it won’t be able to support a lot of weight.
  2. Offset: An offset cane may be beneficial if you require a cane that can sustain more of your body weight than a regular cane or if you have a poor hand grip. It has a flat hold, and the cane’s higher shaft can flex outward.
  3. Multi-legged: Multi-legged canes have more than one leg, as the name implies. These canes provide optimum steadiness, which is crucial if you want to avoid falls and spinal injuries. However, because this cane has more legs, it can be a little hard to use at the beginning.

When buying a cane, ask the following questions:

1. What should I know about choosing a grip?

There’s no right or wrong grip—it’s really up to you what feels most comfortable. As a rule of thumb, though, larger grips are best suited for people who have joint problems, and foam grips or grips that mold to your hand tend to be widely popular.

2. How can I tell if the grip I picked is incorrect?

If you have numbness, tingling, or discomfort in your hands, see your doctor or a physical therapist.

3. How do I learn how to use my cane appropriately?

If you’re considering getting a cane, talk to your physical therapist or doctor first. They will verify that the cane is properly fitted to you and will show you how to use it. It’s critical to work with a health care expert to get the appropriate fit—if your grip isn’t comfortable, or if your cane is too short or long, it might do more damage than good.


Walkers, like canes, are categorized into three types:

  1. Standard: Standard  walkers come with four rubber-tipped legs that give stability and support. However, since this type of walker does not have wheels, you will have to pick it up to move ahead.
  2. Front-wheeled walkers:  This walker has two wheels in the front and two non-wheeled legs at the back. You won’t have to pick up this walker to get around, therefore you’ll save energy.
  3. Walkers with four wheels: They travel the fastest, however it can be difficult to put your weight on these types of walkers. Break or a backrest may be included in some versions. There are different walker glides used for these types of walkers.

When buying and using a walker, consider the following questions:

1. What should I keep in mind when picking a grip?

Solid plastic, non-slip latex, and pliable foam are the most common materials for walker handles, and choose whichever is most comfortable for you.

2. What is the right place to buy a walker?

Walkers are available at pharmacies and medical supply stores. You can also buy a walker on the internet.

3. How can I learn about using my walker appropriately?

It’s understandable if using your walker makes you feel uneasy at first. It may take a little time for activities that were formerly simple, such as getting from a seat to a standing position, to seem normal again. Consult your doctor or physiotherapist for advice on how to properly use your walker and to establish methods for improving your walking in a comfortable manner.

SEE ALSO – Rollator walker review


Canes and walkers are examples of walking assisting equipment that can help you move more effectively, but we suggest using a walker if you’ve gone through a spine surgery which would help you retain your freedom of mobility.  

Rate this post

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *